NFL Soup|Sunday, May 26, 2013
You are here: Home » NFL » NFL.com Top 100: Is Joe Flacco Better Than Tony Romo?

NFL.com Top 100: Is Joe Flacco Better Than Tony Romo? 

The NFL.com Top 100 is slowly being released via television. There was already an uproar when everyone discovered that Tim Tebow cracked the list, and fans were even more upset when they learned that Tony Romo sat just four spots ahead of Tebow on the list, at 91 overall.

Things just got messier.

According to a portion of the list recently released, Baltimore Ravens quarterback Joe Flacco came in at number 74 overall, a whopping 17 spots ahead of Tony Romo. Naturally, the way these two quarterbacks are ranked in a popular list begs the question; who is actually better?

In my opinion, it shouldn’t be a question. I’m not a Cowboys fan and I hold no bias to either quarterback, but it’s clear that Romo is more talented, and has put up better numbers in his career.

Granted, Romo has just one playoff victory to his name, but Flacco has zero Pro Bowls to his name and has stats that can’t compare to what Romo has put up over the years.

Many will point at Romo’s feeble playoff wins and the knee-jerk reaction will be that Flacco wins this debate. However, a closer look suggests that’s not entirely fair.

Take 2011, for instance. Some will say Romo didn’t show up, as his Cowboys failed to claim the NFC East and a playoff spot by beating the New York Giants in the week 17 “winner take all” season finale.

Oh, you mean the Super Bowl champion Giants? The team that beat the 15-1 Green Bay Packers with ease at Lambeau, went into San Francisco and took out the 13-3 49ers, and even shutdown the Atlanta Falcons to the tune of two points in a wild card opener.

And we’re not even to where they, you know, won the league title.

The point is, if you want to start with playoff talk, start with Flacco. Romo lost to the team that ended the year as the best team in football. They didn’t just slap the Cowboys around; they slapped everyone around, and won the Lombardi Trophy.

Flacco, on the other hand, struggled through a divisonal round win against playoff newbies, the Houston Texans. Flacco was so weak in this game, that he was called out by safety Ed Reed, who said the Ravens couldn’t win with quarterback play so shoddy.

In his defense, Flacco did respond in the AFC title game, but it wasn’t enough, as his team once again fell short.

If we’re talking about stats and overall play in the 2011 regular season, I still have to give the golden ticket to Romo. Flacco threw for 3,610 yards, 20 touchdowns and 12 interceptions last year, while Romo bested him in every major category, as he topped 4,100 yards with 31 touchdowns and just 10 picks.

In fact, Romo’s numbers are even more impressive when you note that he got off to a slow start and tossed five interceptions in the first four games of the year. The rest of the way? Just five picks, to go with 24 touchdowns.

Flacco also completed a career low 57.6% of his passes in 2011, while Romo completed 66.3%.

If we want to dig deeper and look at their careers, Romo wins there, too. He’s been far better statistically, as he’s dropped three 4,000+ yard seasons and four seasons of at least 26 passing scores. Flacco hasn’t done any of that.

Further, Romo averages a completion percentage of over 64% on his career. Flacco hasn’t even averaged that for any one season so far.

Let’s recap: Romo has the better numbers both in 2011 and overall, he’s more accurate, and he’s been to Pro Bowls, while Flacco has been to none.

Not sold yet? I don’t blame you, as you’re probably still being held up by Flacco’s post-season success.

However, a fair question is wondering just how much of that playoff success can actually be attributed to Flacco.

After all, he’s always been backed by a grizzly, veteran Ravens defense that excels during the regular season and routinely switches to a whole nother level when the playoffs roll around.

I’ll give Flacco respect for making the playoffs in each of his first four seasons. That’s an accomplishment. But Mark Sanchez made the playoffs in his first two years, too. He even made it to the AFC title game in 2010. Is he better than Romo, too? No, I didn’t think so.

But still, there’s even more evidence to be looked over.

Flacco’s career playoff record isn’t bad (5-4), but his actual performances warrant a closer look. Here’s the breakdown:

2008

Vs. Dolphins (W 27-9) – 9-of-23 for 135 yards, 0 TD, 0 INT

Vs. Titans (W 13-10) – 11-of-22 for 161 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT

Vs. Steelers (L 23-14) – 13-of-30 for 141 yards, 0 TD, 3 INT

Summary: It was his first season, but Flacco survived the first two games with the help of his defense and ground game, and then gave Pittsburgh the game with three picks and inefficient play.

2009

Vs. Patriots (W 33-14) – 4-of-10 for 34 yards, 0 TD, 1 INT

Vs. Colts (L 20-3) – 20-of-35 for 189 yards, 0 TD, 2 INT

Summary: The win over the Patriots had everything to do with defense and nothing to do with Flacco, and then Flacco went on to choke against the Colts.

2010

Vs. Chiefs (W 30-7) – 25-of-34 for 265 yards, 2 TD, 0 INT

Vs. Steelers (L 31-24) – 16-of-30 for 125 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT

Summary: If we’re giving Flacco respect for beating a Chiefs team that had an easy schedule and was overrated, well, that’s just sad. The real Flacco showed up the following week, as he was ineffective in another loss to the Steelers in the playoffs.

2011

Vs. Texans (W 20-13) – 14-of-27 for 176 yards, 2 TD, 0 INT

Vs. Patriots (L 23-20) – 22-of-36 for 2 TD, 1 INT

Summary: Flacco had two scores in round one but was very average and inaccurate in key moments. He did show up against a bad Patriots pass defense, but ultimately they didn’t get it done.

It’s pretty clear that Flacco started to show up in 2011. However, using any of his prior post-season “success” in this argument isn’t fair to Tony Romo, as Flacco was far from the reason his team advanced in the majority of those games.

Romo still needs to exercise some demons, ala Drew Brees has in the past. He’s come close to getting over the hump, but it just hasn’t happened for him yet. I believe it will.

In the end, you’ve got two quarterbacks who are very far apart in terms of talent and production, while one has benefited immensely from a superior defense and rushing attack. Romo has better passing weapons and is in an offense that loves to throw. But if he had a consistent running game and a defense that backed him up at all, he’d likely have more playoff success by now.

Last, but not least, when you consider the fact that Romo went undrafted and Flacco was a first-rounder, it’s even easier to be more impressed by Romo.

About the author: Kevin Roberts

Kevin Roberts owns and operates NFL Soup and heads the fantasy football division of the site. Roberts also finished 2nd in the Wide Receiver position in Fantasy Pros expert fantasy football rankings in 2010 and 3rd in the Quarterback position in 2011. In addition to running the fantasy football section of the site, Roberts contributes to NFL Soup's NFL Draft coverage and breaking news reporting. Follow Kevin on Twitter @NFLSoupKevin

16 Responses to NFL.com Top 100: Is Joe Flacco Better Than Tony Romo?

    • Texas

      He also had Laurent Robinson who nobody had herd of and turned him into a 32.5 million dollar man. Miles Austin wasnt even drafted, so who knows where he would be if he hadnt had Romo.

       
      • @NFLSoupKevin

        Good call. Outside of TO, Romo made most of the guys around them better than many other quarterbacks probably would have.

         
    • @NFLSoupKevin

      Didn't the Giants just win the Super Bowl twice in the past 5 years? The Eagles have been a playoff-type team for the majority of that stretch, too. I wouldn't exactly call the NFC East a cakewalk. I'll give you the weapons argument. Romo has always had a better supporting cast. But his division has been equally difficult when you think about it. Baltimore is one of the top teams in the AFC North. Other than them it's just the Steelers. It's not really a tough division when you're one of the two competitive teams.

       
  1. Mulletcork

    Flacco is the far superior QB to Tony Bromo.

     
  2. @BruHaHa222

    There is really no legitimate argument for Flacco in this debate.

     
  3. @MCxShow

    Just to double-check and clarify, isn't the "Top 100 Players of 2012" based on each players individual, single-season performance from 2011? (You know, the same way NFL Network based the "Top 100 Players of 2011" on the 2010 season, which is when Tom Brady was No. 1 due to his 36:4 TD:INT MVP season.) If that is the case–going off their performances in 2011 alone and nothing else–Romo deserves to be ranked higher than Flacco due to superior numbers with less to work with, despite not reaching the postseason. Romo completed 66.3% of his passes for 4,184 yards with 31 touchdowns to 10 interceptions. (Oh and did I mention that Romo did this even while Miles Austin and Dez Bryant missed playing time due to injury?) Meanwhile, Flacco completed only 57.6% of his passes for 3,610 yards with 20 touchdowns to 12 interceptions. Additionally, half of the Cowboys losses came against playoff teams, while the Ravens losses came against teams with losing records. The only thing Flacco has over Romo is making it to the playoffs, but the Ravens didn't make it to the Super Bowl anyway, while the Cowboys lost twice in a month to the eventual champions. So as for the 2011 NFL Season: Romo > Flacco

     
  4. @MCxShow

    And on an unrelated note, how the hell is Vincent Jackson nine spots ahead of Jordy Nelson!? Jackson whined about his contract and acted immature, having the worst season of his career by catching 58 passes for 961 yards and four touchdowns, while also not returning a single kick/punt for a touchdown in his career. Nelson, on the other hand, wasn't flashy, but rather a team player, and had a breakout year with 68 catches for 1,263 yards and 15 touchdowns! (The NFL.com/top100/2012 list even has Jackson voted as overrated, while Nelson is voted underrated.)

     
    • @NFLSoup

      we probably just have to be glad a white wide receiver gets that much respect these days, ha. sad, but true. I get your point, and I'm a fan of Nelson, but is he actually better than V-Jax? I would say no. Nelson has the better quarterback, team, offense, etc, too.

       
      • @MCxShow

        Oh my God do I look like an idiot right now. I meant to say DeSean Jackson, not Vincent Jackson. D-Jax had those stats yet was still ahead of Nelson. I honestly believe Vincent Jackson is better and will be ranked higher, but DeSean Jackson should not be ranked higher than Jordy Nelson based off of the 2011 season. That is my bad and I apologize for making myself look like an idiot now.

         
  5. andrew

    flacco hasnt had the same weapons as romo and everyone knows this. also you are attempting to compare #'s when romo has been around a lot longer than flacco. how about you compare the simple record of wins/losses? flacco has romo beat pretty good on that one over the last few years. all bc the cowboys got beat by the super bowl champs (before they were champs) means jack shit; what was the giants record? guess that means every team that beat them during reg season was better… the ravens play against much better defenses then the cowboys also. look at the big picture. flacco is younger than romo and has more football left in him then romo. he also normally makes smarter plays as romo tends to force passes or attempts to run and ends up short. to bad romo wont ever take you anywhere since he is the master at playoff busting.

     
  6. test

    Hi there to all, how is everything, I think every one is getting more from this site, and your views are fastidious for new viewers.

     
  7. Filmy hiszpańskie

    I like this send, enjoyed this one show gratitude you for putting awake. “He removes the greatest decorate of friendship, who takes missing beginning it respect.” by Cicero.

     
  8. Super katalog

    of course like your website but you need to check the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling issues and I find it very troublesome to tell the truth nevertheless I’ll certainly come back again.

     
  9. monstrous

    of your way more technologically sophisticated mountain bikes accessible. Even though having a entrance and

     
  10. Primerica Scam

    Based on my research, after a the foreclosure home is available at an auction, it is common to the borrower to still have some sort ofthat remaining balance on the mortgage loan. There are many creditors who try to have all expenses and liens paid back by the next buyer. Nonetheless, depending on specified programs, regulations, and state guidelines there may be a few loans that are not easily handled through the exchange of financial products. Therefore, the responsibility still falls on the borrower that has received his or her property in foreclosure process. Thank you sharing your notions on this website.

     
  11. oferta firmy Glassland.com.pl

    I became reading the posts, and I definitely go along with what John said.

     
  12. Humberto Spanfellner

    Each is diverse, resilient, and offer you one of the most help, footing and padding from the athletic sneakers. jeremy scott footwear is among the list of finest jogging sneakers offered on the market. These sneakers have distinctive components designed by the particular Adidas Business. Although jeremy scott footwear is created away from really difficult materials

     
  13. Brittaney Pollok

    One thing is that one of the most prevalent incentives for making use of your cards is a cash-back and also rebate offer. Generally, you’ll receive 1-5% back on various expenses. Depending on the card, you may get 1% returning on most expenses, and 5% back on purchases made at convenience stores, filling stations, grocery stores plus ‘member merchants’.

     
  14. ugg cleaners

    We’d like to make certain that trip on your very first cyberspace acquire Ugg Boots Offer, to their total birthing in your hunter wellingtons will be as toned as you

     
  15. sydney tiles

    I think this internet site holds some real excellent info for everyone. “The individual will always be a minority. If a man is in a minority of one, we lock him up.” by Oliver Wendell Holmes.

     
  16. http://youtube.com/watch?v=xbL01vfSggg

    Thanks for the sensible critique. Me and my friend were just preparing to do a little research about this. We grabbed a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I am very glad to see such magnificent info being shared freely out there.

     
  17. Doug

    The the subsequently occasion I read a weblog, I beyond doubt chance as a result it doesnt disappoint me roughly brussels. Extend proceeding, chap, Agreed, it was my option to recite, on the contrary I merely thought youd have a quantity of fixation exciting to testify. All I be made aware can be present a great covenant of whining concerning a little which you could fix should you werent too active thorough for attention.

     
  18. bags61iv

    ugg bailey button triplet grey boots 2012 early spring new arrival hottest style on saleSuède. Suisse. Syrie. Serbia,クロムハーツ. Seychelles. Sierra Leona. Also,Coach Wallets,Coach Jewelry in Coach Outlet and Coach Outlet Online Store sell very well in international market for its fantastic specifications and designs. What’s more ,the good after-sale service makes these articles more competitive compared with others. Now, Login Louis Vuitton Handbag On Sale to choose your favorites. Just as with cars, secondhand bicycles can be found easily online. There are many sites with classified, more or less specified. New designs keep coming every other day. Stocks / Availability of Items : Stocks for items listed in my blog are not kept in hand. They will be ordered once I receive your payment. All other stuffs are ordered fresh from the US. I took a picture of the belt that I came in with! ” Then she was like! “You don’t have to be upset and raise your voice. I’m just telling you store policy,ポールスミス 財布.” So I was like! “Well! I took a picture! What are you going to do about it,クロムハーツ 財布? “. We thought that we were the only ones not happy with this store! I just read some of the reviews on the side bar! and I am not feeling bad at all giving THIS STORE AND ITS MANAGEMENT a 1/2 star at most. Shopping alcoholics can . Karmaloop could possibly be one of the options for this. Not only are you choosing among colors,ポールスミス 店舗, patterns, and what it is made from, but there are also a variety of .. DLNA allows you to streaming content from other DLNA devices,saisinporusumisu/, such as your computer, to be displayed on your TV screen. It provides excellent images (Full HD 1080p/24 video output) and sound (Dolby TrueHD DTS-HD MA) quality on both standard blu-rays and 3D blu-rays. It can up-scale DVDs to 1080p,クロムハーツ 店舗.. Le mariage a d but loin de toute la sainte. Modifier D placer Raymond fondamentale Universit chur vocal Charlie Angrisano vit ainsi piste les enfants vangile, ce genre de doux minuscule en ce qui concerne mon propre. Les particuliers qui s’accumulent associ s int gr s et aussi des promoteurs concernant Retirer de soutien des enfants, sans risque Orient en ce qui concerne Supprimer, Supprimer Comit Contre mauvais traitements Fille, SupportLink / Domestic Assault M thode inattendue R pondre d’urgence et de spot attendant. Jak wejdziesz pierwszy raz na naszą witrynę, wytłumaczymy Ci wszystko. W naszym asortymencie odszukasz wiele korzystnych rabatów dla świeżych kontrahentów. Jeżeli zaś jesteś naszym wiernym kontrahentem, bądź pewien, iż będziesz miał sposobność skorzystać z wyjątkowych promocji,ポールスミス. Related articles: 4664/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=621863 nosnowkennels/suesblog/2009/10/meet-the-dogs.html#comments

     
  19. best1451

    It is very essential to build the exact manner of sense on the regulars and contacts. Uniforms of your employees reflect how well-built your brand name is. Hence it is essential to decide on the right uniforms for your workers. Fashion has never been constant for a long duration of time. In fact people’s sense of fashion changes faster than the changing seasons. It is a commonly observed fact that women have always dominated in the trend setting department,クロムハーツ ネックレス. 8 million years after that book became a commercial success! the customer is relatively Selfridges so much, The middle class increasingly fetishized Western fashion,nyu-baransudendou/, as it was visible but not easily obtainable,ニューバランス 996. Making them unshapely and uncared for which might negatively impact the subconscious opinion other people who get to see the victim get to make about the victim. The 2nd diverse is often to go. By the time you’ve got discovered a search engine optimization Seo business to complete your advertising and marketing campaign, it’s going to be about 4:thirty, and you may be ready to indicator the deal. Ensure you read it carefully, being totally confident that it’s what you need. Taking the added 50 % an hour to look at all the great print could just conserve a headache within the future.. Apart from these, BaByliss Nano Titanium and Ceramic hair dryer with model number BNT5547C is supported by one year limited warranty. An online boutique with more than eight years experience in the scenario Flat Iron Experts would be one of the best ways to shop this high quality hair dryer at superb rates. Apart from blow dryers,ニューバランス 574, it also has in its product line items such as flat irons,kouhyoukuromuhatu/, curling irons, heat setters and rollers, and beauty care cosmetics. SalsaThe red tomatillo salsa has 40 calories, 2 g of protein, 510 mg of sodium, 8 g of carbohydrates, 6 g of fiber,ニューバランス レディース, 1 g of sugar and 1 g of fat. The green tomatillo salsa has 15 calories, 1 g of protein, 230 mg of sodium, 3 g of carbohydrate, 1 g of fiber, 2 g of sugars and no fat. The corn salsa has 80 calories, 3 g of protein, 410 mg of sodium, 15 g of carbohydrate, 3 g of fiber, 4 g of sugar and 1.5 g of fat. John Deere, Harley Davidson, Twisted X and Old Gringo Boots are just a few of the brands of mens cowboy boots available in the market. There are different designs that you can choose from that would match your own style and personality,Chrome hearts ネックレス. If you want, you and your son can even have matching pairs and believe me your son would love that. Related articles: bbs.studentsbbs/ fzhdbycom.www1.91e0/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=389513&extra=

     
  20. best7589

    how to accessorize with replica handbagsIt’s reall a discouraging project chooseto choose dimensions,クロムハーツ 財布, stle,Coach Outlet tpe after which colour of backpack. lv handbags are loved b any agelots of women, you will findsince you will find tpicall different advantages to have the ability to with this chic add-ons. Modern popularit from pouch coloration provides be refined whenever ou wish far more lots of women going throughhave prosperous relevant toconnected with brand-new sparkl colorations showing their very own stle as well as existence to be able to people. There also a stigma that the Suns don play defense. That just not true. They have moved up to 19th in defensive efficiency, which is impressive because they were in the 26th range earlier this season, and I sure they in the top half of the league over the last 35,ニューバランス レディース. Do not use the iron on wet or damp hair. This t-shirt usually features a stylish logo,ニューバランス. It has become a popular casual shirt, especially at sporting events. Warm water works regarding cleaning available teeny in addition to shed position along with nightfall coming from Louis Vuitton Bags On Sale all materials involving LV lv handbags discounted Purses and handbags specifically individuals have already been pre-treated. However! Do not use appliance to do the washing laundry. These fragile baggage can not accept your do-it-yourself torture associated with highly effective swirling h2o. Your body should be straight in a 45-degree angle. Try to avoid pushing your hips to high as this causes hyperextension in the lower back, arching,クロムハーツ ネックレス. Hold this position for five seconds. Aquolina, the brand that brought you the ever-popular perfume Pink Sugar, also brings you Chocolovers. However this perfume is more a chocolate-suggestion than anything else. A warm spicy orange accord creates a wintry, creamy effect that’s a little reminiscent of chocolate,ニューバランス レディース. Loafers are another popular choice, with the Monte Carlo Loafer being a top brand. This pair is available in either cacao,ニューバランス スニーカー, which is a deep brown color, or noir, which is the darkest black possible. The quality is evident in the hand stitched cal leather uppers while comfort is maintained in the supple rubber soles that have been carefully padded. Now it has entered the mens comfort wardrobe and defi ,ニューバランス 574. A few style tips to re-incarnate your t-shirts are: Style a solid colour t-shirt with printed maxi skirt and add an accent colour skinny . The new shirt design may explore and invent new techniques and finishes like the wrinkle free or super soft cotton but never deviate much from the classics. Related articles: jita.5d6d/ ahmscm/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=10821

     
  21. testrotl

    Individuals can easily get a safe mode of operation through the availability of internet at home with portable payment and invoicing. People can enjoy the next generation possible access to variety of banking payments. By consuming client application enabling of real time transaction is also effective in this regard,ニューバランス 574. PotentialIf you want to maximize your fat-burning potential,waribikikuromuhatu/, incorporate interval training into your workouts,ニューバランス 574. This will not only cause you to burn more calories while you exercise, but it will also raise your metabolism for several hours once you are done. Start your workout with a light 5-minute warm-up, then step at a fast pace for 20 seconds. These storylines all came together with Kurt’s solo performance, which is already leading me into a campaign for him to have more of them over the course of the next season or two. It was moving, and most importantly it was subdued — usually performances on “Glee” are the exact opposite. This was quickly followed up by another duet between Will and April,saisinporusumisu/, which was really a more energized version of what Kurt had to sing.. The mouth may break into a smile or exhibit cynicism,クロムハーツ. The nose may be turned up when you feel uncomfortable with someone, show disdain or a haughty emotion. Imagine being able to hide all this behind face masks!. The gown is quite minimal in its draping. It is strapless and consists of a bow detail in the waistline. Cocktail Dresses Under 100. Check the logo. Logos are often a slip-up area for copies. They may have spelled the name slightly differently, such as Carter instead of Cartier. It looks sweet and lovely,クロムハーツ ネックレス. Some LV handbags have thick fur outside,ニューバランス 996. This hairy style is suitable for women to use in the winter, because it looks very warm.. A big part of the appeal of a Louis Vuitton bag is the fact that they are so exclusive, the cost makes them unattainable for the vast majority of people. Louis Vuitton come in a wide variety of styles so ouis vuitton monogram canvas bags on that you like really shouldn’t present a problem. Although the majority of them are made out of leather you can actually get them made out of several different materials. It is light on pocket and easy to buy. They are appropriate for all the occasions like marriage, dinner etc. Our High quality replica handbag are becoming more and more popular as women around the world try to achieve the latest fashion look without paying thousands of dollars for one designer high replica handbag. Related articles: zjkxyw/b/article.php?type=blog&cid=5&itemid=59936 laligue85/usep/guestbk.php

     

Add a Comment